read all posts in book reviews read all posts in entertainment read all posts in get local: houston read all posts in motherhood Read all posts in Personal Read all posts in Product Reviews Read all posts in Tech Read all posts in Travel Image Map

Whose Labor Is It Anyway?

I rarely watch TLC’s “A Baby Story,” I guess because I’ve been through it five times myself, and I don’t need any dramatic reminders of all that childbirth entails.  I happened to land upon the show today, though, and the episode I watched had me both angry and horrified.

The couple – first-time parents – had opted to partner with a midwife for a water birth.  I missed some of the details because…well…I’m a compulsive channel-flipper, but when I next saw the woman, she was in active labor and begging her husband to get her an epidural.  He, the doula, and the midwife kept stalling her.  At least the husband had the compassion to explain that he thought she would later regret having gotten an epidural.  The midwife just gaffawed at the woman behind her back, telling the camera, “I’ve NEVER seen someone come in after just a few hours, 2 centimeters dillated, already ready to give up!”

The woman kept repeating how much pain she was in, she kept saying “someone please help me, nobody’s listening to me,” and it really seemed like nobody was.  At one point she told the doula, “I need help!” and the doula answered, “You’re going to have to help yourself.”

I was just astounded that this was happening.  The show sprinkled in some post-labor interviews, and the woman confessed that she was really upset no one was listening or abiding by her wishes for pain relief.  She did not, in fact, regret her choice for pain relief.  What a heart-breaking first labor experience to have!

Finally, finally!, they allowed her to have an epidural.  The doula stood to the side and told the camera, “You know, some ladies come in with just the best intentions, but then a natural childbirth just isn’t for everyone.  And you know,” (insert totally condescending voice here) “it’s o-kay.”

Oh, this whole thing just got my blood boiling.  This was not some cheesy horror movie where one character says to the other:  “No matter what you hear in there, don’t come in!”  I mean, birth plans CHANGE – it’s so hard to anticipate how everything will go down.  But first and foremost, someone should be listening to woman in labor!

I’m glad I’ve already been through all this five times before, because I’m telling you, if I was a first-time mom and saw that show, I’d be totally terrified of my own labor day.

You might also enjoy these related posts from Tree, Root, and Twig:

  1. Headline: Housewife Makes Startling Discovery, Goes to Bed Before Midnight
  2. One Mother, Two Women

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

468 ad
  • http://waterwatereverywhere.blogspot.com MainlineMom

    I’ve seen the episode you speak of before and yes, I had the same reaction. Pure anger, mostly at the husband but certainly at the doula. I’m all for giving women choices when it comes to THEIR birth plan, but for pete’s sake let it be THEIR CHOICE. Epidurals are not evil! Mine did not exactly work right, and even though my labor never got to the active state, I needed that epidural to get a little rest during my 26 hours…before my C-section. Women’s bodies are all different and its virtually impossible to tell how your body will labor…anybody that says different is just wrong.

  • http://waterwatereverywhere.blogspot.com MainlineMom

    I’ve seen the episode you speak of before and yes, I had the same reaction. Pure anger, mostly at the husband but certainly at the doula. I’m all for giving women choices when it comes to THEIR birth plan, but for pete’s sake let it be THEIR CHOICE. Epidurals are not evil! Mine did not exactly work right, and even though my labor never got to the active state, I needed that epidural to get a little rest during my 26 hours…before my C-section. Women’s bodies are all different and its virtually impossible to tell how your body will labor…anybody that says different is just wrong.

  • http://ldscancermom.blogspot.com LCM

    It sounds like maybe she should’ve had a safe word, some sort of, “I am seriously not kidding when it comes to this.”
    I can’t tell you how many times I have watched that show and seen them tell the woman that a birth plan is just that, a plan, not a set in stone, concrete thing to have happen. Maybe the doula and midwife should’ve been reminded of that.
    I labored at a 1-1 1/2 for over 12 hours and it was so painful, I couldn’t wait for my epidural.

  • http://ldscancermom.blogspot.com LCM

    It sounds like maybe she should’ve had a safe word, some sort of, “I am seriously not kidding when it comes to this.”
    I can’t tell you how many times I have watched that show and seen them tell the woman that a birth plan is just that, a plan, not a set in stone, concrete thing to have happen. Maybe the doula and midwife should’ve been reminded of that.
    I labored at a 1-1 1/2 for over 12 hours and it was so painful, I couldn’t wait for my epidural.

  • Laurie L

    I too have seen this episode, and it made me angry and THANKFUL to have wonderful doctors who know me well and can tell what my limitations are. I had my first child after a 6 hour labor with no pain medicine whatsoever, but my second was a different story entirely. My doctor knew that I wanted to do it naturally, but after 7 1/2 hours of painful and exhausting labor he GENTLY suggested that I consider either an epidural or something to take the edge off the pain at the very least. I made it another hour before asking for the epidural, and had 5 more hours of labor following it. I was so thankful to have someone who was so in tune with me to help me through my labor! I have not regretted having the epidural for one second.

  • Laurie L

    I too have seen this episode, and it made me angry and THANKFUL to have wonderful doctors who know me well and can tell what my limitations are. I had my first child after a 6 hour labor with no pain medicine whatsoever, but my second was a different story entirely. My doctor knew that I wanted to do it naturally, but after 7 1/2 hours of painful and exhausting labor he GENTLY suggested that I consider either an epidural or something to take the edge off the pain at the very least. I made it another hour before asking for the epidural, and had 5 more hours of labor following it. I was so thankful to have someone who was so in tune with me to help me through my labor! I have not regretted having the epidural for one second.

Our Life in Instagrams